Does the Self Matter?

The next question that comes to my mind with this “Self business” is

Does the Self really matter?

After all, it’s been pointed out by others on my blog, as well as in certain religions and philosophies, that the “self” doesn’t really matter. Some even believe that the most important goal in life is to do away with a Sense-Of-Self, to “die to yourself”, and even to embrace the whole of life as illusion.

Now, that may be fine for some. If that works for them, that’s great. But it’s not for everyone — and it’s certainly not where I’m coming from. Self matters deeply to me, and it does to other folks I know who are overcoming difficulties which challenge their Sense-Of-Self. Everywhere I look, I encounter people who are struggling with understanding who they are in this dynamically changing world, what place they have in their re-organized increasingly global workplaces, who they are as they recover from life-threatening illness, and what their future holds as they go through life stage and career changes, lose loved-ones to sudden, unexpected death, and otherwise grow and develop as people.

For those dealing with TBI, especially, I think that Sense-Of-Self is a critical ingredient — especially in recovery. A Sense-Of-Self might seem like a luxury, when you’re in the process of learning to walk and talk or just get through your day without melting down and screwing everything up. But I truly believe that Self does matter — and in ways that are crucial to the very processes of learning to walk and talk and get through your day without melting down and screwing everything up. The question of Self is not the domain of philosophers and chaplains alone. It’s not just some academic or theoretic path to wander down, when you don’t have anything more important to think about. It’s a core and central part of TBI recovery, and if it’s not properly tended to and rebuilt, that can have dire consequences for a survivor’s long-term prospects.

Self and our sense of who our Self is permeates every aspect of our lives. It’s inescapable, it’s ever-present, and even it its “broken” form (as it often appears when your identity is fractured after a traumatic brain injury) it plays a huge role in how we go about our lives and how we seek out meaningful and lasting change — for better or for worse.

Self matters, because it’s who we are. It’s how we define ourselves. It determines where we put our attention and our energy, and it gives us a sense of purpose and place in life. When you lose that, you lose a truckload of reason to go on — the very thing that can keep you going through the long, arduous work of recovery from TBI.

Self also matters, because it’s who we are to others. It’s the “user interface” that makes possible interactions in social situations. Understanding “who” others are, is the glue that makes community possible. It’s not some simple-minded concept that can be disposed of, for the sake of “spiritual evolution”. Our public Self, as well as our private Self, is the vehicle that our personalities use to find our place and fill our space in the world. Our Sense-Of-Self is what makes life meaningful and gives us direction. Only by knowing what matters to us, and how we think and feel and believe, can we live lives that are more than base existence. And we practice that picking and choosing, each day of our lives, as we mature and grow and build the personalities that carry us through life and connect us to others.

When we don’t know what matters to us… what we think and feel and believe… we cannot help but feel cut loose from our moorings. Because we are. When we haven’t figured out what matters to us, we drift… and misfortune fills those gaps, as often as not. When we have no Sense-Of-Self, we have no rudder to guide us as the winds and tides of life push and pull us. And everyone around us knows it, too. They need us to have a clear Sense-Of-Self, so that we can participate in their world, connect with them, and provide support and ballast as they weather the seas of life, as well.

Both privately and publicly, Self does matter. Not only do we orient ourselves in life and manage to get on with our daily lives, based on our Sense-Of-Self, but the rest of the world relates to us as it perceives us. I’ve had many, many experiences where people made snap judgments about me, based on how they thought me to be. They decided (pretty much for themselves) who they thought I was, and they interacted with me based on that perception. Some say “perception is reality”, but when people are perceiving you to be able to easily do certain things that are a profound challenge for you — and leave you exhausted for days afterwards — that concept doesn’t hold up.

Maintaining a stable public persona, and being able reinforce your Sense-Of-Self around others is the one thing that makes socializing work. Showing up each day as a slightly different person doesn’t just undermine your self-confidence; it challenges the trust of everyone around you, who is accustomed to dealing with you in a certain way. Even if their perceptions of you are flawed and far from the mark, the stability of their perceptions is what supports social interaction. People may actually know that they’re wrong about you, and you’re wrong about them. But as long as everyone is wrong in a consistent manner that makes predictable social interaction possible, the wheels can keep turning freely in the communal machine.

When you’re shaken by TBI, many of the old connections in our brains and our nervous system can get severed, frayed, damaged — some of them severely. (I’m peripherally including the central and autonomic nervous systems — spinal cord, too — because these are the delivery systems that transport the electrical impulses that guide our experiences and expressions of self.) And that has repercussions for everyone involved.

In an instant, the systems that that used to make it easy to be who and what you are, just don’t work the way they used to. Noises that used to be fine, suddenly bother you. Sunlight that used to be so nice to see, is now a source of pain and suffering. Taste and smell and touch can be affected. Your balance can be thrown off — sometimes so severely, that you’re so busy trying to stay upright that you don’t have the bandwidth to pay attention to things like what people are saying to you, or the bigger picture beyond your immediate struggle to not throw up. Memory can either disappear, or be so eroded, that you can’t carry on a full conversation with someone because you keep losing the train of the conversation. And fatigue… well, when you’ve got so little stamina that you can’t make it through the day without a four-hour nap, there’s not a whole lot of room for much else in your life, other than managing your energy and doing damage control.

Without warning, with TBI, in a very real sense we become someone different. The differences may be drastic and obvious, or maddeningly subtle and invisible to anyone but us. The changes may be immediate, and some of them may be gradual, sneaking up on you over time. But they do happen. Often without our control or say-so.

Suddenly, the old ways of doing and being in the world are no longer available to the extent they once were. Things that used to be easy and effortless become a chore and a struggle. Getting dressed in the morning becomes a trial by fire, with none of the steps seeming obvious. The kitchen where you fix your breakfast becomes an obstacle course, apparently designed to drive you crazy. Sometimes abilities that used to be second nature to us disappear entirely, seemingly never to return. The old “bad” habit of lying suddenly doesn’t work, and you can’t keep your story straight. You try to draw, but you have a hard time holding your pen, and you get so tired with the effort, you can’t finish anything you start. Your conversations with people you know and like turn into social minefields, with the constant threat of misunderstanding threatening to derail the relationships. The one-cool demeanor that you had under any and all conditions… well, that’s gone… seemingly forever. Driving during rush hour becomes a gauntlet from hell.

Little by little, these problems erode not only your self-confidence, but also your relationships with the rest of the world. People who are accustomed to dealing with one sort of person, need to either accommodate a new person in your place, or they just quit dealing with you at all. You have a different way of speaking, a different way of looking at people, a different way of carrying yourself. And the people around you who built up an entire interactive repertoire around the person you were, must suddenly deal with someone who is not upholding the unspoken rules of social interaction.

As small behavioral social anomalies balloon into faux pas and outright failures, not only is your self-confidence undermined even more, but your relationships are eroded and function less fluidly. Part of it is you, part of it is the rest of the world. The downward spiral becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. And if you manage to figure out there’s a problem before it threatens to destroy your life, you’re one of the lucky ones.

With TBI, the once-known is now unknown, the once-familiar becomes strange (or disappears entirely), and challenges crop up where they “shouldn’t” be. And that deviation from the norm, that separation from the old familiar ways which tell us who and what we are, can be utterly devastating. When we lose our old, dependable fluidity and ease with the activities that once made us productive human beings who knew our place in the world, we literally lose our Selves. We no longer know exactly who we are, why we are alive, what our purpose in life is. We no longer know where we fit in the world, in our communities, in our extended families and social contexts. The parts of ourselves that used to be so fluid and easy… that feeling of familiarity and ease, well, it’s pretty much gone.

It needs to be rebuilt.

Now, many of the problem areas may be “fixable” to some extent. The brain is magically plastic, and it creates new connections and new wiring where it needs to. It’s now commonly known (contrary to scientific prejudice of past decades), that the brain will “recruit” different parts of itself to do the job of parts that have been hurt or damaged. Our brains — and our spirits — are incredibly resourceful, that way. And as we now know, there is not only ONE part of the brain that does ONE thing at a time — areas for speech and language comprehension are a lot more distributed than we used to think. Plus, different people have different areas that handle the same sorts of functioning. Everyone is unique and different that way, and the brain’s substantial ability to recover and restore at least some of its functionality is nothing sort of miraculous.

The thing is, under these circumstances when the brain is trying to build back its lost functionality — irony of ironies — even more energy and focus is required. Going through the motions every day to make up the difference between then and now (and teach your brain to do things a little differently than before) so you can keep yourself on track takes a whole lot of energy and a whole lot of focus — just at the time when you have less energy and less focus than ever. Which, frankly, sucks. It’s one of the worst things about TBI — at the very time you need more resources, more time, more direction, more of just about everything… you actually have less.

On top of this, you may not even realize you need more energy and focus. All you know is, things aren’t going right. Things aren’t working out like they used to. You’re having trouble and you don’t understand why. In the face of unidentified difficulty, you can just keep going the same way as you did before, trying like crazy to get things right — and perhaps getting a little better each day — but running out of steam in the process, losing your focus and what cognitive capacity you have, and ending up on the business end of the cosmic cattle prod over and over and over and over and over and…

When you get stuck in that loop, even more fuel, more determination, more drive is called for. And you may in fact be getting better a little bit at a time — or even a whole lot, seemingly out of the blue. But regardless of your rate of improvement, you need to keep going. You need to keep up the level of effort required to get your brain back on track — and your life, too. TBI is a lifelong condition that demands continual, consistent mindfulness. It sounds a little exhausting, when I think about it, and maybe it is. But the alternative is the equivalent of wading mindlessly into a swamp filled with snakes and alligators listening to dance music in noise-cancelling headphones, obliviously splashing around to the beat, whilst the snakes and ‘gators circle closer.

So, where do you find the inner resources to keep up your mindful vigilance? Where do you get that drive to keep going? From the Self, your individual identity, the core character of your soul. As I mentioned before, I believe that Self is a collection of unique traits and activities that are familiar to us, which we recognize as Who We Are. The familiar pieces are the parts of us that are easiest to express, the ones that require the least amount of work to do. The easier these parts of us are to express, the better they feel, and the more we want to do them. And the more familiar they become through repetition, the better they make them feel when we do them.

On top of it, the more familiar our behaviors are to others, the easier we make it for them to interact with us. When we present predictably to others, they can develop an interactive repertoire that defines who we are – and who they are when they relate to us. It’s no small matter, our Sense-Of-Self, for it defines not only us, but our larger community as well. When people know us as stable, predictable personalities, it lends to repetition and familiarity. And the more familiar we are to others, the better they feel when they’re with us – provided, of course, they are comfortable with who they become when we’re around.

This need to “feel good” is not some hippie-dippy self-indulgence — it’s central to who we are and how we see ourselves fitting (or not fitting) in the world. It can be subtle and hidden beneath the surface in our unconscious, but it’s there. We have to have this feeling of goodness and rightness inside us, to some extent, or where will we find the reason to live? It’s not optional, it’s not elective. We must — to some extent — be able to feel good about something about ourselves. The Self needs a really good reason to survive – both individually and collectively.

Now, the familiar (good) feeling can come from some pretty rotten behavior, or everyday routine, or truly noble actions. But in any case, the behavior needs to feel familiar and easy and fluid, in order to feel like US. That fluid, easy feeling is really the foundation of who we are and how we perceive ourselves, both in our lives and in the larger world. It’s the fuel that keeps us going. It’s made up from the sum total of rewards and consequences of our behavior and our interpretations of the meanings of our experiences as “good” or “bad”, “positive” or “negative”, as well as the rush (or deadening effect) that we get from all these things. This in turn determines the types of things we’re willing to do, and to what extent we’ll do them.

When your wiring gets crossed and you start behaving in ways that are unfamiliar to you, you can start to doubt yourself, and your source of motivation can get cut off. And if that source of motivation is cut off, even for a short time, it can jeopardize even the most hopeful recovery. The impact is felt not in just one single area, not a single limb or organ or idea, but in complex combination of ways of doing and being which weave together the very fabric of a person’s identity. Without coherence of that Self, without the certainty of Who You Are, things can start to slip and get lost, like sand carried in a bag made of thin gauze.

And that matters. Because if there’s one thing that everyone agrees on — experts and survivors alike — it’s that TBI can take a lot longer to heal than anyone expects. YouTube has plenty of videos from people who started out on their recovery 1000% determined to “beat this thing” by any means possible. And over time, they learned that they had a much longer way to go than they ever expected. It can be heart-breaking to watch their accounts and see them gradually sinking into a state of resignation and defeat. All too often that happens. Because TBI takes time. More time than just about anyone suspects.

It also tends to happen differently than most people expect. I, myself, have often thought that I could “get back” to how I was before, if I just worked hard enough. But you know what? It doesn’t work. The person I was before is gone. And funneling all my energy into “getting back to where I was before” is a losing battle that takes my attention and energy away from more productive activities, like finding out what other parts of my life I can develop fresh and new. I’ve struggled and battled and hassled over trying to restore certain functionality that I had in abundance before my last accident, but in doing that — which, ten years later, is still not working out — I have been missing out on other areas of my life I can develop which are really interesting and intriguing and offer me a chance to make a fresh start — a fresh start I’d been needing for some time, anyway.

Sometimes our old abilities return to some degree, but by its very nature, brain injury causes permanent damage on some level. The precise formation of our brain’s old familiar circuitry has been disrupted, so nothing works exactly the same anymore. We can rebuild similar connections in different ways, but once axons are sheared, chances are pretty good that they’re not going to be knitted back together exactly the way they once were. Sure, people may tell you that you’ve got a good chance for recovery, and that may be true. But with certain once-simple activities now being so hard, who can say if things will ever be exactly the same again? Chances are, they won’t. It’s like bending a metal pipe and then trying to restore it to its original shape — it can’t be done. Although the pipe may work fine, possibly even better than before, there will always be a little crimp in the metal that will never go back to its exact original structure.

At the start of our recovery, we may have thought (and said out loud to anyone who would listen), “I can beat this thing!” and believed it with our whole hearts. Everyone around us may have said the same thing. Chances are, we threw our whole Selves into the work, but when we realized that our old Selves were changed, and we didn’t have the same abilities as before, that “hit” to our identity pulled the rug out from under us. Suddenly, nothing works quite the same anymore. Some things are the same, others are different, but it’s impossible to tell just how different they’re going to be in the future – and when.

You get up from your chair, and you start to fall over from vertigo.

You step outside on a bright sunny day, and you’re blinded by the sunlight that gives you a pounding headache for the rest of the week.

You hang out with friends at a pub, and you find that you can’t stand the sound of the jukebox. And that pint of beer hits you harder than it ever did before.

You start to argue with family members over “nothing” — and you end up weeping uncontrollably for hours with no idea why.

You get a good night’s sleep each night, but you still wake up exhausted, and you can barely function after four hours.

You talk to friends about things you know you should remember – they certainly do – but you can’t remember a thing. And when they walk away, 15 minutes later, you have no idea what you were discussing.

And each time you have these kinds of experiences, they’re just a little different from the last time. You never know how things will turn out – for good or for ill.

None of it makes sense. None of it seems real. None of it is like you used to be. But it’s how things are now. Except that it’s not. Next week it could be entirely different.

Even if we’ve been making good progress with logistical things — like getting up and ready for work — and our progress has been steady, the continued feeling of unfamiliarity can make us doubt our progress, and undermine the determination which is so important for our continued improvement.

“Why is this still so hard?” we might ask ourselves. “Why am I not better yet?” We may actually be better, but it doesn’t feel that way. And nothing that anyone says to us can change our perception that we’re not better. We just don’t feel that way at all. Even if we can find a renewed purpose, we have to find new ways of pursuing it, and that work can be physically exhausting, emotionally depleting, depressing, and spiritually draining… which makes us doubt ourselves, our worth, our ability to function as normal people in the world.

It’s particularly hard, if people around us are expecting us to “get back to normal” and be like our old selves again. Our old selves are gone-baby-gone, and nobody wants to hear our tales of woe about how hard it is to just keep going under the present circumstances. It may not be obvious on the surface that we’ve changed, but we can tell inside that something is different. Others can, too, though they can’t quite put a finger on it. And the added difficulty of having to re-think so many parts of our lives can put a serious drain on us.

What’s more, it puts a serious drain on our social connections.

When it comes to TBI recovery, there are very few elements more important than one’s connections with other people. We are by nature social creatures. Our brains are social organs. So much of what we do and are is geared towards interacting with other people, and when we’re denied or deprived of that interaction, disruptions and disorders can follow.

It’s my personal belief that much of the mental illness and logistical dysfunction that comes in the wake of TBI is rooted in social isolation… or a growing alienation from the world around us. TBI can make it next to impossible to work with others, or for others to work with us. Mood disruptions, unexpected outbursts, agitation, fatigue, difficulties paying attention and remembering what people are saying to us, all contribute to this, as do physical issues like light and noise sensitivities.

Plus, people who knew us before, may not be comfortable with us as we are now. Either our injury makes them nervous – it’s hit too close to home and they don’t want to think that it could ever happen to them. Or the way we are after our injury is different from what they expect – in subtle or obvious ways.

In some ways, it’s the subtle changes that make things hardest. We all develop our interactive repertoires with one another, largely due to unconscious cues like body language, inflection in our speaking tones, pacing in conversations, and minutely detailed connections we make which identify each other as “friend” or “foe”. When our way of being – the way we speak, the way we act, the way we move – becomes unfamiliar, we can unconsciously become “foe” to our former friends. It’s rarely conscious, but it happens. A lot.

The thing is, we need to be around people to get better. We need feedback from others to understand how well our strategies are working. We need to have models and examples to follow. We need people. And they need us. When we pull (or are pushed) away from social situations because of our difficulties, TBI survivors lose important opportunities to modify our behavior to become more functional, and recover from our injuries. And the people around us lose the opportunity to broaden their own worlds and perspectives.

If you don’t have a clear Sense-Of-Self, or your Sense-Of-Self is under constant revision, dealing with others can be very difficult. It puts you on edge, first of all, and that doesn’t help you interact productively with others. It also doesn’t give others much to work with. Interacting with someone who doesn’t know who they are, or who is constantly changing their mind and their mode of being, is a little like climbing up an icy hill. If a person doesn’t have clearly distinguishable unique characteristics — opinions, beliefs, tastes, thoughts, etc. — there’s nothing for other people to react to reliable, socially speaking. Thus, the interactions can get slippery.

And that all leads to more agitation, more irritation, more difficulty. You’re like a ship with a broken rudder tossed about in the stormy seas. You don’t have anything to guide you, anything to steer yourself in the right direction. And the same goes for them. If they don’t know who “you” are, they don’t have a clear sense of who your Self truly is, they have no way to reliably know if they’re being socially successful or not.

Not having a clear Sense-Of-Self is not much help at all.

To anyone.

It’s tough. Things are not as they once were. They’re different. We’re different. A part of us has died, and another part of us is being born. But we’re often so tied up in just handling the logistics of basic survival, that that gestation and birthing process isn’t immediately apparent to us. Who are we? Who can say?

And yes, that matters. Because TBI recovery is not a simple, straightforward path, which can be designed and predicted and carried out in just the same way with different people each time, with just the right results. The brain is involved. People are involved. The elusive quality of human experience is involved. All three are unpredictable, mysterious, and confounding in their own right. But a combination of all three? And under less-than-ideal circumstances?

If someone who’s trying to come back from TBI has no clear Sense-Of-Self, no clear mission, no coherent vision of themSelf and their place in the world, how can they be expected to continue with the ongoing work of trial-and-error recovery?

How indeed?

Now, I suppose it’s entirely possible to try to recover without having a clear Sense-Of-Self. You can flounder and flail around, take shot after shot at things that used to (and might still) matter to you, and try like crazy to make up for what you’ve lost. You can also rely on others to provide you with direction and tell you what should and should not matter to you, what you should and should not do. But if you have no true sense of who you are and what you’re about and what matters most to you, the fuel for that kind of activity is bound to run low, before long. There’s only so much help you can expect to get from outside.

And that’s a problem. Because if you’re involved in the long-term (sometimes life-long) work of building your life back after TBI, the one thing you’ll need is a reliable source of fuel. Motivation. Caring. Investment. Only the survivor can know what it’s like to be in their skin, dealing with their differences, and only they can take the actual steps to keep themselves going in the right direction. Without that inner fuel of a healthy and evolving Self-image, the inner AND outer work can’t get done. It might get started, but progress can remain elusive. It may even regress over time.

And that is why the Self matters. Because it’s what keeps us going through the long, sometimes difficult process of TBI recovery. Deep within, in that innermost seat of the soul, lie the seeds of recovery which need protecting and feeding and tending to sprout and grow strong. We’re not just talking about a single seasonal crop, either — we’re talking about ongoing growth, ongoing development, ongoing re-development of our abilities and understanding of our place in the world. In the center of the Self, we find the material of improvement, the fuel for the long journey which will never end, so long as we are living on this earth.

It’s the same for everyone — brain-injured or not. We all need healthy Selves, to be healthy humans. But for the brain-injured, especially, a healthy Sense-Of-Self is as critical to long-term healthy prospects as clean air and water, exercise, nutritious food, and the support of a caring community.

 Back to the Table of Contents >>